Zisk StatementTragardh StatementWest StatementCastelli StatementBallesteros StatementShapiro Message

Newscenter

Office of Public Affairs

Barnard Public Calendar

Barnard Bulletin Board



Comments of Paige West
Assistant Professor of Anthropology, Barnard College

I have been amazed by what I have seen in New York City in the week following this disaster. One thing that I have observed is a phenomenon that is explained very well by the people I work with, as an anthropologist, in the rural mountains of Papua New Guinea.

When people travel to far away places, places that are quite different from their homes, they tend to seek out other people that they imagine are like themselves. Whenever I travel in Melanesia I am amazed by encounters with other Americans where in the span of 20 minutes they will have told me all about their lives and I will have told them all about mine. I am stunned sometimes by sitting around a table full of Americans who don't know each other at all but who are having dinner and laughing and talking without barriers or suspicion. I'm not talking about nationalism or Xenophobia here. This is different. It is similar to what anthropologists have called a "community of sentiment," which means people coming together because of shared social bonds, feelings, and history. But that anthropological explanation does not really do it justice.

In New Guinea there is a phenomenon that is termed "Wontok" in Melanesian Pidgin. Wontok is literally translated as "one language" but it means much more than that. A Wontok is sometimes someone who speaks the same language as you, but it is also someone with whom you share a set of social obligations.

If your Wontok needs something you will do everything in your power to provide her with it. If your Wontok is hungry you will feed her. If your Wontok is injured you will find her medical care. If your Wontok needs to build a new house you will help her. If your Wontok is sad you will comfort her. While you can be born into a Wontok system, that is not always the case. You can marry into the system. You can live with people in the system and become one of them. If you become a part of the social world of the system you are a part of it. After years of working in New Guinea now, I am a Wontok to the Unavisa Gimi. So are my husband, my mother, my grandmother, and my best friends.

Although I just started teaching at Barnard two weeks ago, I have been a New Yorker for a while now and in the past week I have been touched and amazed by all of my Wontoks here. And again, this is not Nationalism I am talking about. It is the simple yet infinitely complex realization that we are connected in social ways that are sometimes beyond our comprehension. What I want for all of us is for us to retain the understanding that we are all Wontoks in the days and weeks and months and years to come. That is a tall order, but I think we can do it. I think that we have to, to live sanely and socially in what has become an insane and unpredictable world.

 

©2001 Barnard College | Office of Public Affairs | 3009 Broadway, New York, NY 10027 | 212-854-5262